Evaluation

Each student will be evaluated on the individual contributions as well as the overall result. When you turn in the final pages of your book to be bound, also them turn in any other notes and/or sketches you used throughout their process. This should include any pdf files from the Process section. To get your final bound book, you will need to turn in the one page discussion paper. The entire project is worth 20 points.

 

0 1 2
Points Possible:

Individual

 Writer
  • poor writing
  • boring story
  • repeated sentence structure
  • decent story, lacking plot
  • boring sentences
  • story follows organized plot
  • varied sentence structure
  • interesting story
8
Illustrator
  • repeated same image
  • poor quality (stick figures)
  • boring images
  • same size on every page
  • rushed
  • pictures accurately represent text on the page
  • images are original, clear and well done
  • varied images
Editor
  • grammatical mistakes
  • lengthy sentences and run-on's
  • too much on a page
  • a few mistakes
  • some run-on's
  • no grammatical mistakes
  • writing is clear and concise
  • text is divided evenly among pages
Designer
  • same page layout on each page
  • little variety in page layout
  • each page is organized with good composition
  • varied page layout
  • text and image work well together
Overall  
  • boring story
  • one person did all the work
  • poor quality
  • one person didn't contribute
  • conceptual story idea is interesting
  • final book is a collaboration of each group member
6
Paper and Notes  
  • didn't turn in anything
  • turned in some papers
  • incomplete
  • turned in notes and printed pdf files
  • turned in discussion paper
4
Presentation  
  • monotone reading
  • no practice
  • boring reading
  • little practice
  • group picked a good reader
  • practiced reading variety
  • read enthusiastically
2
Total        
20