Evaluation

Evaluation

These rubrics show how you are going to be graded. It is important that you review these grids in order to have guidelines and an understanding of what will be expected of you. Now it is especially important that your group work cooperatively. You will all be receiving the same overall grade for the completion of your project.

Proposal Guidelines

	Poor 0 pts	Fair 5 pts	Good 10 pts	Excellent 15 pts
Content	Did not address any of the required questions	Addressed only a few of the required questions	Addressed most of the required questions	Addressed all of the required questions
Clarity	Main points were unclear and hard to follow	Main points were somewhat clear but hard to follow	Main points were clear but not concise	Main points were clear and concise
Presentation	Proposal was unorganized and messy	Proposal was somewhat organized	Proposal was organized but lacked in overall neatness	Overall proposal was well organized and neatly presented
Spelling and Grammar (see printed copy for specific errors)	10 or more spelling and grammar mistakes	6-9 spelling and grammar mistakes	3-6 spelling and grammar mistakes	0-3 spelling and grammar mistakes
Cooperation	No cooperation when creating proposal	Some difficulty in cooperating with others in group while creating proposal	Group cooperation was evident in creation of proposal	High levels of cooperation evident in creation of proposal

Presentation Guidelines

	Poor 0 pts	Fair 5 pts	Good 10 pts	Excellent 15 pts
Content	Did not address any of the required questions	Addressed only a few of the required questions	Addressed most of the required questions	Addressed all of the required questions
Clarity	Presentation was unorganized and hard to follow	Presentation was somewhat organized but hard to follow	Presentation was clear but not concise	Presentation was clear and concise
Participation in Presentation	Presentation dominated by only one group member	Student participation was not equally distributed in the presentation	Each group member participated in the presentation	Each group member played a significant role in the presentation
Body Language	Students showed no composure during presentation	Students had trouble maintaining composure during presentation	Students' composure was somewhat professional	Students' composure was mature and professional